His argument is as thin as the homeopathic soup that was made by oiling the shadow of a pigeon that had been starved to death.

Share this quote

About this quote

Line strips away polite language and calls out hollow reasoning for what it is: empty and performative. Stop mistaking clever phrasing for proof; strengthen claims with facts, effort, and clear action. Ask yourself where your case lacks substance and take practical steps to fill the gap.

When to use it

  • During a team meeting, call out a proposal that has no data behind it by quoting the line and then ask for concrete metrics and a timeline.
  • Use the line in a performance review to push a colleague to stop leaning on excuses and instead present a realistic plan to improve.
  • When evaluating your own plans, read the sentence aloud and see if your reasons feel equally insubstantial—then rebuild them with specific actions.
  • In a debate or policy discussion, use the image of the line to demand evidence rather than stylish language, and require accountability.